NY Hospital for Special Surgery Sends Recall Letters to Exactech Vantage Ankle Replacement Patients

The Hospital for Special Surgery in NYC sent letters to current and former patients warning them about a recall of the Exactech ankle replacements. 

The letter says that some patients are having problems with the VANTAGE Fixed-Bearing Polyethylene Liner Component and VANTAGE Mobile-Bearing Polyethylene Liner Component. The implants are at risk of wearing out much earlier than expected. The vacuum bags used to store the inserts may have been exposed to oxygen and could cause the implant to wear out.

If you received one of these letters from HSS, contact us immediately to preserve evidence and protect your rights.

Hospital for special surgery
HSS in New York City


Exactech wants you to contact their helpline, but the information you give them could hurt your case if you choose to file a claim. You could be signing your rights away. Contact the lawyers at mctlaw first if you received a recall letter from HSS.  We can request your medical records on your behalf and review them to see if you have a claim. And we do this at no cost and at no obligation to you.

Received a Warning Letter from Hospital for Special Surgery?

Contact us now about your Exactech Ankle Replacement. We can help you preserve evidence and protect your rights.

What is Wrong with Exactech Vantage Ankle Replacements?

Exactech admitted that the vacuum bags used to store the liners were not correctly packaged before surgical use and that about 80% of their inserts manufactured since 2004 could be defective.

The bags should have two layers. The bags did NOT include a second layer of ethylene-vinyl alcohol that helps enhance oxygen resistance. This could cause air to enter the package and lead to a chemical process called oxidation. When exposed to oxygen, the liner may corrode.

With daily use in the body, the oxidized plastic liner can degrade and release particles into the body that cause tissue damage, pain, swelling, and other symptoms. Now patients are finding that their Exactech ankle implant needs revising after a few years when they should last for 20 years.

Exactech worked closely with the Hospital for Special Surgery to research and develop joint replacements.

Exactech and HSS have a partnership to research and design joint restoration replacements.


It’s essential to hire an attorney based on experience. The law firm you hire should have the financial resources to litigate against giant corporations that will try to derail your lawsuit. mctlaw has the resources, expertise, technology, and knowledge to help you get the best possible outcome. 

The attorneys at mctlaw do not sue orthopedic surgeons. The problem is with the medical device and the manufacturers, sellers, and distributors who misled surgeons to believe the product was safe. Often your surgeon can help your case.

  • Mctlaw has focused its practice on defective joint replacement cases for over a decade.
  • Our attorneys are leading the litigation against artificial joint makers across the country.
  • Our firm does not refer out Exactech cases. If we take on your case, we represent you.
  • Mctlaw represents you at no cost unless we recover money from a verdict or a settlement. If you don’t get compensation, you owe us nothing.

Watch for Possible Symptoms of a Defective Exactech Ankle Replacement

Symptoms of polyethylene wear are usually related to bone loss or excessive particle debris released from the degraded liner. 

But some people may suffer bone loss, also called osteolysis, without any symptoms at all.

Make sure you contact your doctor to see if you need to monitor your implant for potential future issues, even if you don’t have symptoms now.

Symptoms to watch for include:

  • Clicking on your ankle
  • Inability to bear weight
  • Instability
  • Noises such as grinding coming from the implant
  • Pain while walking
  • Swelling in the joint

If you have any of these symptoms, contact your doctor right away. They can discuss treatment options, including potential revision surgery to replace the defective insert or the entire device.

Most importantly, call the team at mctlaw to review your case. The lawyers at mctlaw filed some of the first cases in the country against Exactech and are in the beginning stages of investigating these claims.

Find out right now if you have a claim

Your case review is free.  Don’t wait to get help because it could hurt your case.

My experience with mctlaw for my hip claim was remarkable, I found the communication to be outstanding. I also felt they did an excellent job setting expectations and then delivering on those stated expectations. From net amount, timing of the settlement, how much each related party would receive etc. they were outstanding. I would highly recommend them. They are very professional and set the bar in vaccine injury practice.


Five stars for mctlaw! Paralegal Leslie Williams did an outstanding job communicating with us and keeping us informed. Thanks for all the help.


I am excited to be receiving my final payment so I can put all this behind me. I am really grateful to everyone who played a part in getting me this well deserved settlement as my life has been negatively impacted over the years.


We cannot thank you enough for the services your firm has provided for Marie and I in our time of need. I could not have chosen a finer firm near or far to represent us.

John and Marie (Last Name Withheld for Privacy)

My first response is “Wow!” It has only been 11 months since I first heard of “SIRVA” and an HHS program that awarded compensation to its victims and only 7 months since MC&T accepted my case. I feel that your efforts on my part made all the difference.

A. Stoneburner

Thanks to you I am living comfortably in my own home with assistance. After my devastating GBS diagnosis from the flu vaccine six years ago, I didn’t know what to do. Thank goodness I found you and your law firm. Thank you so much!

Name Withheld for Privacy

Alison is a phenomenal attorney… When she put together the demand letter she was able to explain what I had been through and how I had felt… I want to thank your firm but personally thank all that had a hand in resolving my case.

Name Withheld for Privacy

The past 10 months have been a whirlwind to say the least but we are truly thankful, grateful and appreciative of …all you have done for our family. This is truly life changing for us. The weight that this lifts off of our shoulders and the peace of mind it will give us….its priceless. So again, thank you.

Name Withheld for Privacy of a Minor Child

Thank you so much. It was so nice to deal with someone who treated us with respect and had a true interest in our future. This would not have happened without your hard work. Please tell anyone who helped with this that we truly appreciate it.

Martin (Last Name Withheld)

I am so grateful for all of your time and tireless work that you have put into resolving my case. Most sincere thanks.


I just wanted to thank you for your help over the past 3 years…Thank you for negotiating with the DOJ in order to get as much as we could under the circumstance…It has been a pleasure having you and your wonderful staff here to assist me in this long and tedious effort.

Name Withheld for Privacy

Thank you for all of your efforts all along to help resolve lifelong issues I will always have due to this defective implant. You have held my hand through a lot and each and everyone of you at MCT are appreciated for all of your efforts.

Name Withheld for Privacy

Mr. Maglio, I want you to know the appreciation I have for Diana Stadelnikas and her team for the effort they have put into my wife’s claim! The settlement negotiation they achieved (in a very frustrating situation) is outstanding! While there’s a way to go yet, I want to assure you will they have my full confidence and gratitude to the finish! I know you must be proud of your people!


I thank you so much for your diligent and hard work on my behalf. You are a thoroughly professional and pleasant person and I am grateful for having you on my case.

Susan M.