Metal on Metal Hip Replacement Lawsuits & Settlements

Metal on Metal Hip Replacement Lawsuits

The attorneys at Maglio Christopher & Toale, P.A. filed the FIRST metal-on-metal hip lawsuit in the United States, so we have a long history in this type of litigation.

We represent clients against nearly every metal on metal hip manufacturer in the orthopedic industry. We have a deep understanding of how the orthopedic hip community works, along with extensive medical and technical knowledge about defective metal on metal hip replacements.

mctlaw is leading the litigation against metal hip makers across the country.

We are currently reviewing cases involving the following hip brands:

Metal on Metal Hip Replacement Cases Across the United States

Click on each state to view the number of cases.

What's Wrong with Metal-on-Metal Hips?


When a person with a metal on metal hip walks or moves their hip joint, the metal head (or the "ball") and the metal cup of the implant rub together. This friction causes microscopic pieces of cobalt and chrome to flake off and enter the hip cavity and the bloodstream, causing heavy metal poisoning or metallosis. These tiny metal particles can destroy bone, nerves, and muscles around the hip.

Organ Damage

The metal particles from the hip wear are so small that they travel throughout the entire body and can cause severe reactions in organs like the heart, brain, and kidneys. Some metal hip patients experience unusual symptoms like skin rashes, heart failure, hearing loss, vision loss, mental impairment, kidney failure, or thyroid problems. However, because the science is fairly new that links systemic organ injuries to metal on metal hips, it is difficult to make these arguments in court. The physical damage to the bone and muscle around the hip joint associated with MoM hips is a much stronger case in court.

No Symptoms

Our staff has talked with thousands of MoM hip patients and discovered that many of them say they had no symptoms, yet blood tests usually showed unusually high metal ion levels in their bloodstream. Leading orthopedic surgeons recommend patients with metal on metal hip implants get blood tests for metal ion levels every 3 months as long as they have the metal on metal hip, EVEN IF THEY HAVE NO SYMPTOMS.

When to Get Blood Testing

Leading orthopedic surgeons recommend patients with metal on metal hip implants get blood tests for metal ion levels every 3 months as long as they have the metal on metal hip, EVEN IF THEY HAVE NO SYMPTOMS.

Questions About Filing a Lawsuit

How do I know if I have a case?

Our Firm will review your information to determine if we can represent you. We might even be able to review some of your medical information over the phone. Often, we need the following documentation:

  • Orthopedic surgeon’s office chart
  • Operative reports for the original joint replacement surgery and the revision (if performed)
  • Device record for the original surgery from the hospital chart (this shows the product and lot numbers of the components of the device)

We can help you track down many of these records. Once our attorneys complete your review, they’ll tell you if we can represent you in your case. However, due to the unique complexity of each case, there’s no one formula to determine if you do or don’t have a viable case.

Why mctlaw does NOT sue orthopedic surgeons:

We do not represent patients in lawsuits against orthopedic surgeons because, in defective hip replacement cases, the problem is with the device, not the doctor. Often your orthopedic surgeon can actually HELP your case.

We believe the companies that made the hip replacements misled surgeons about the safety of their products.  That’s why we limit our representation strictly to prosecuting manufacturers, sellers, and distributors of defective joint replacements.

Can you represent me even if I don’t live near your offices?

Yes! Our lawyers represent people across the entire United States. We are a nationwide litigation firm with regional offices in Washington DC, Seattle, WA, and Sarasota, FL.

When it comes to hiring an attorney, make your choice based on experience in this specific field. These are high profile medical product liability cases. Overall, the law firm you hire should have the resources to manage your case against huge multi-national corporations.

Is there a deadline to file a defective hip replacement lawsuit?

Yes, definitely. There is a limited period of time to file a lawsuit for injuries suffered as the result of a defective product. Therefore, do not delay in getting more information because it could hurt your case.

Do you collect and refer cases? Because I don’t want that.

No. Absolutely not. mctlaw is not a referral mill. Our attorneys represent injured clients across the country in defective medical product liability cases. We work in partnership with the Kansas City, Missouri law firm of Nash & Franciskato on all metal on metal hip replacement cases.  Our Firms do this to more effectively represent our clients across the nation with defective metal on metal hip replacements. Subsequently, our attorneys are your direct contact in all aspects of your case.

How much does it cost to hire our Firm for a metal on metal hip replacement case?

There is no cost to you unless we recover money from a verdict or a settlement. Our Firm charges a percentage of any settlement or judgment.  In other words, if you do not receive any compensation at the end of the lawsuit, we get no fee and you owe us nothing.  mctlaw does not make a practice of referring out our cases to other law firms. We represent YOU.

Why Hire the Attorneys at Maglio Christopher & Toale, P.A.?

mctlaw has focused its practice on defective hip replacement cases for over a decade. Our Firm filed the first lawsuit involving a modern generation model metal on metal hip replacement in the United States in 2008. Find out what kind of experience any attorney has in litigating orthopedic joint replacement cases.

Complications From Metal on Metal Hip Replacements

Heart Failure | Cobalt Cardiomyopathy

Particles of metal are released from the metal hip implant into the bloodstream, which then can travel around the body. This leads to the hip implant causing issues with many areas of the body other than just the hip. There is evidence that metal on metal hip replacements may cause heart problems and failure in patients.

Cobalt Chromium Toxicity

Cobalt and chromium metal debris from metal on metal hip replacements can end up in a patient's bloodstream. This may trigger a hypersensitive immune response in their body.


ALVAL is short for Aseptic Lymphocyte-Dominant Vasculitis-Associated Lesions. Essentially, ALVAL happens when metal particles from the implant interact with the body's immune cells, causing the body's defense system to act like it's being attacked.


A pseudotumor is a large, solid, or semi-liquid mass of soft tissue growth inside the body, usually around the hip joint. They are associated with metal on metal hip replacements, and typically form as a negative reaction to the metal debris.


A type of metal poisoning that involves a build-up of metal debris in the body's soft tissue.

Vision Loss

When metal ions from metal on metal hip replacements are released into the bloodstream, cobalt-chromium levels rise. this may lead to metal poisoning, which associated with vision loss.

Hearing Loss

When metal ions from metal on metal hip replacements are released into the bloodstream, cobalt-chromium levels rise. This may lead to metal poisoning, which is associated with hearing loss.

Metal on Metal Hip News

Types of Defective Metal on Metal Hips

Zimmer Biomet Magnum M2a

$56 million dollar settlement offered if you filed a claim in court by June 13th, 2014. Even if you missed the settlement deadline, we are still accepting “out-of-deadline” cases.

DePuy Pinnacle

In March 2016 a jury in Dallas, Texas awarded a $500 million dollar verdict to five patients with defective Pinnacle hip implants.

Stryker Rejuvenate & ABG II

$1.43 billion dollar settlement announced. We accept cases that are part of the settlement and also cases NOT covered by the settlement dates.

Zimmer Durom

Our attorneys filed the FIRST metal on metal hip replacement lawsuit in the United States in a case against the Zimmer Durom implant.


$2.5 billion dollar settlement only applies to patients who had a revision surgery BEFORE January 31, 2015. We accept both cases within the deadline and cases NOT covered by the settlement.

Wright Medical Conserve

First recalled in 2004 because of defects in the cup. Now patients are reporting metal poisoning from the Conserve implants.